Brothers Pizza Β· 402 George St N

PETERBOROUGH FINALLY HAS A PIZZA SHOP WORTH Staying Open Late For.

Open tomorrow at 11 AM β€” or call us now: (705) 745-7766
CLOSES AT
12AM
Thu Β· Fri Β· Sat

Every good pizza place in this city closes early. So after that? Your only option is the chain everyone complains about.

You've been settling. Not because you wanted to. Because nothing better existed. That stops here.

Brothers Pizza makes our dough fresh every morning β€” here, in this building, not shipped frozen from a warehouse. We load the toppings. We run our own delivery. And Thursday through Saturday, we stay open until midnight.

No frozen dough. No $15 vanishing into an app before your food even leaves the kitchen. No chat bot when something goes wrong. Just real pizza. From real brothers. Who answer the phone.

Whether it's midnight on a Friday or 8 PM on a Monday β€” we make it fresh and we get it to you hot.

"Since purchasing from Brothers Pizza, we have never once been disappointed, nor have we ordered from any other pizza joint." β€” Peterborough Customer Β· Google
1,200+
Orders & Counting
15MIN
Avg. Delivery
4.8β˜…
Google Rating
<30MIN
Guaranteed Hot

"Our pizza comes out of the oven and straight to our delivery drivers."

β€” Faheem, Co-Founder & Head Chef

Skip the Middleman.
Three Ways to Order Direct.

No app. No fees. No inflated prices. The $15 they would've taken? It's yours.

🌐
Order Online

Our site. No app. No fees. No inflated prices. Takes 2 minutes. Works on any phone. No account needed.

NO FEES. EVER.
Start Your Order β†’
πŸ“ž
Call to Order

A real person picks up. Every time.

(705) 745-7766 Call Now β†’
πŸƒ
Pickup

Ready in 15 minutes. 402 George St N, Peterborough

15 MIN READY TIME
Get Directions β†’

New here? Already on Skip? Either way β€” call (705) 745-7766. Takes ten seconds, saves you $15, and if anything's ever wrong we fix it. No chat bot. Just us.

🌾
Made This Morning. Not Last Tuesday.

Dough made in-house every day. Never shipped frozen from a factory.

πŸ’Έ
No App. No Driver Making Three Other Stops.

We run our own delivery. Your food moves from our oven to your door.

πŸ“ž
We Pick Up the Phone.

Call (705) 745-7766. Real people. Real fix. Every time.

πŸŒ™
Open Until Midnight Thu–Sat.

When every good place has already closed. We haven't.

Tired of Settling?
Here's Why It Kept Happening.

You didn't choose bad pizza. You ran out of options at midnight. That's not the same thing.

❌ The Chains & The Apps
❌
Frozen dough. Every time.
A former chain employee said it plainly:
"Dough comes as frozen discs about 1/8 inch thick. All meats come in frozen. Cheese comes in frozen. There is literally no fresh food prep."
❌
Your $13 order costs $34.
Add the delivery fee. Add the service fee. Add the menu price the app quietly inflated. Then add a tip. A Peterborough customer documented it β€” $13 poutine, $34 final bill. It went viral because people couldn't believe the receipt was real. It was.
❌
Nobody to call when it goes wrong.
"I brushed my teeth and am going to bed because the app failed to deliver our order after 3 hours."
❌
After 10 PM, your options drop to zero β€” or worse.
That's what a city looks like when every quality option closes at 10.
βœ… Brothers Pizza
βœ…
Made This Morning. Not Last Tuesday.
Fresh dough. Made in-house. Every day. You'll taste exactly what that means.
βœ…
Order direct. The app loses. You win.
No delivery fee stacking. No service charge buried in the total. The $15 the app was about to take? It stays in your pocket.
βœ…
We pick up the phone.
Something wrong? Call (705) 745-7766. A real person answers. We fix it.
βœ…
Open until midnight β€” Thursday through Saturday.
When every quality option closes at 10. We don't β€” on the nights that matter most.

One phone call. One real person. One pizza made this morning. That's the whole difference.

Order Direct β€” Keep Your $15 β†’

A $13 Poutine.
$34 on the App.

Real receipt. Went viral.
Your order through the app:
Poutine$13.00
Delivery fee+$5.99
Service fee+$3.49
Small order fee+$2.00
Priority fee+$3.99
Suggested tip+$5.00
You Pay$34.47
πŸ•
Apps take 20–30% commission
Restaurants earn 4–12% profit. The math makes every app order a loss β€” so they cut ingredients to survive.
πŸ“¦
Your food pays the price
Cold. Late. Wrong order. That's not bad luck β€” it's the app model actively degrading both ends of the transaction.
πŸ“ž
Order direct from us
We keep the margin. You get better food for less money. No middleman. No markup. No mystery driver.
πŸ†
Everyone wins except the app
The app loses. You win. We win. Peterborough wins.

πŸ’Έ The $15 you just saved? That's a free side of wings. Right now.

Order Direct β€” Keep Your $15 β†’ πŸ“ž Or call now: (705) 745-7766
Real Peterborough Customers

What They Actually Said.

Tried their walk-in special with 3 toppings and was pleasantly surprised by the generous amount of toppings and how delicious the pizza was. Great location in downtown Peterborough and I really liked the friendly service. I would definitely try other menu items next time.

Kevin Chuang
Google Β· Local Guide Β· Peterborough

It has become our regular spot. They ran out of goat cheese one night for an order β€” wasn't a big deal β€” but they went out of their way to go find more to make sure our pizza was perfect. Amazing guys! Great service! The BEST pizza!

Jay McAuley
Google Β· Local Guide Β· Regular customer

From pizza to burgers, Brothers Pizza has it all. The price is reasonable, the portions are large, the products are fresh and the food is delicious! A great addition to the downtown core. Great service by Faheem and his team. Always a pleasure stopping by!

Laura Montague
Google Β· Local Guide Β· 322 reviews

We ordered 2 pizzas β€” Mighty Caesar and Meat Lovers. Took about 10–15 minutes to get our fresh pizzas and WOW were they delicious. The crust, the sauce, the toppings, everything was so good and cooked perfectly. Will definitely return and totally recommend!

Jenn
Google Β· Local Guide Β· 276 reviews

Kind staff. Fair price, and the pizza is excellent πŸ‘Œ Food, service, and atmosphere β€” all 5/5.

Thomas Morales Braun
Google Β· Local Guide Β· Peterborough

Brother Pizza is one of our favorite spots! Their pizza is always fresh and made just right with great toppings. The wings are just as amazing β€” perfectly cooked and full of flavor. The service is always friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend!

Farzad Sultani
Google Β· Local Guide Β· 97 reviews

Deals That Make Ordering Direct Even More Obvious.

Add app fees to any of these and you're paying for two meals. Order direct and the math speaks for itself.

BROTHERS PICK
Brothers Specialty Pizza

Our signature pizza. Full size. Made this morning.

$30.99
Order direct β€” no delivery fees added.
Order Direct
QUICK & LOADED
Large Two

Two large pizzas. Every Friday. Every time.

$31.99
Order direct β€” no delivery fees added.
Order Direct
FRIDAY NIGHT PEACE TREATY
Family Meal Deal

Two large pizzas + wings + drinks. The peace treaty. Thu–Sat.

$51.99
Order direct β€” no delivery fees added.
Order Direct

We're Brothers.
This Is Our Place.

Co-Founder & Head Chef
Faheem

Faheem runs the kitchen. Every day, from the moment the dough goes down to the moment the last order leaves the oven, he's in it. He made the call that Brothers Pizza would never use frozen dough β€” not because it would be marketed that way, but because that's the only way he knows how to make pizza.

"I'd rather you get too much than too little. Every single time."
Co-Founder
Fisal

Fisal handles everything people don't see β€” the sourcing, the supplier relationships, the reason the ingredients we use are actually what we say they are. He makes the pizzas, runs deliveries, and is the one who picks up the phone more than anyone else in this building.

"People are surprised when a real person answers. That's the whole point. That's what we're supposed to be."
Peterborough Is
Where We're From.

Peterborough isn't just where we work. It's where we grew up. It's where we went to school, watched the Petes, and drove down Lansdowne hungry β€” with exactly one late-night option, and it was bad.

We remember exactly what that felt like. And we decided it wasn't good enough anymore.

So we built the place we wished existed. Open when you need it. Fresh when everything else is frozen. Answering when nobody else picks up.

When something goes wrong with your order, you're not calling a 1-800 number. You're calling us at (705) 745-7766. We answer. We fix it. That's the whole model.

That's not a marketing line. That's just Peterborough.

Order From Our Team β†’

Don't Take
Our Word For It.

Peterborough is a small city. Word travels fast here. If the food is bad, everyone hears about it. If it's great β€” same thing.

β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

"If you're in Peterborough and thinking about ordering from a chain β€” PLEASE do yourself a favour and reconsider. This place is a hidden gem."

Verified Customer Β· Restaurant Guru Β· Peterborough
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

"Since we started ordering from Brothers Pizza, we have never once been disappointed β€” and we have not ordered from any other pizza place since."

Regular Customer Β· Google Review Β· Peterborough
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

"I ordered late night delivery on Sunday. Their garlic sauce is the best I've had in all of Peterborough."

Verified Customer Β· Restaurant Guru Β· Sunday midnight order
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

"Food is always good and always hot when delivered. Love it β€” even being on the other side of town."

Delivery Customer Β· Google Review Β· East City
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

"For 37 dollars my husband and I got a caesar salad, poutine and poppers, including tax and delivery across town. Great value."

Couple Order Β· Google Review Β· Peterborough
β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…β˜…

"Killer pizza with an over the top amount of toppings. I ordered at midnight. It showed up in 25 minutes, still hot."

Late-Night Customer Β· Google Review Β· Midnight delivery, Peterborough
Convinced? Good. Now let's get you some pizza.
Order Now β€” We're Open β†’
⭐ Leave a Review

Loved Your Order?
Tell Peterborough.

Peterborough is a small city. When you leave a review, you're not just helping us β€” you're helping the next shift worker, the next Trent student, the next family who's about to settle for a worse option because they didn't know we existed.

⭐ Help Peterborough Find Us β†’

Thursday. Friday. Saturday.

When every other good place
has already called it a night β€”
We haven't.
When the Petes game ends and everyone's still hungry.
When Friday night runs longer than planned and the fridge is empty.
When the study session finally wraps and someone sends the group chat one message.
When the bar closes and everyone in the group chat agrees on exactly one thing.
When Saturday ends and everyone's too hungry to go home yet.
Open until midnight, Thursday through Saturday.
Order Now β€” We're Open β†’ πŸ“ž (705) 745-7766 β€” we pick up.

Your Order

No products in the cart.

Find locations near you

Discover a location near you with delivery or pickup options available right now.